Difference between revisions of "Talk:TCPA/TCG - Trusted or Treacherous"
(new) |
(Plagiarism?) |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
--[[User:Pitsche|Pitsche]] 11:38, 4 Jul 2005 (CEST) | --[[User:Pitsche|Pitsche]] 11:38, 4 Jul 2005 (CEST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Plagiarism? == | ||
| + | |||
| + | Large parts of this article apparently consist of unattributed, near-verbatim excerpts from a SANE2004 paper by Weis, Lucks, and Bogk, [http://www.cryptolabs.org/CCC2004TCunendlich/WeisLucksBogkSane2004tcg12.pdf TCG 1.2 - fair play with the 'Fritz' chip?]. Regardless of whether one believes that general political/ethical concerns about Trusted Computing belong on a Thinkpad-specific site, wholesale copying of unidentified, and presumably copyrighted, material is not cool, and could get the whole project in trouble. | ||
| + | |||
| + | I would suggest that the non-original parts of this article be removed and replaced by an external link to the above-mentioned paper; any particularly crucial short excerpts (as permitted by "fair use") should be clearly identified as such. The specific information about how the TCG specifications are implemented on various Thinkpad models can stay, of course. | ||
Revision as of 16:18, 4 July 2005
Discussion about the article "Trusted or Treacherous"
Please add you comments here.
You can use the "Plus"(+)-Button next to the "edit"-button at the top of this page to add you comments at the right spot ;-)
--Pitsche 11:38, 4 Jul 2005 (CEST)
Plagiarism?
Large parts of this article apparently consist of unattributed, near-verbatim excerpts from a SANE2004 paper by Weis, Lucks, and Bogk, TCG 1.2 - fair play with the 'Fritz' chip?. Regardless of whether one believes that general political/ethical concerns about Trusted Computing belong on a Thinkpad-specific site, wholesale copying of unidentified, and presumably copyrighted, material is not cool, and could get the whole project in trouble.
I would suggest that the non-original parts of this article be removed and replaced by an external link to the above-mentioned paper; any particularly crucial short excerpts (as permitted by "fair use") should be clearly identified as such. The specific information about how the TCG specifications are implemented on various Thinkpad models can stay, of course.
